A little more than a decade ago,
Querevalu's 8-ton wooden boat rarely returned with an empty hold as it
does on this day motoring back to Lima's port of Callao, the low-slung
clouds above as gray as the sea mirroring them.
"There used to be
fish for everybody," the 48-year-old trawler captain laments, leaning on
the rail as a stiff breeze buffets his leathery brow. "You'd run into
immense schools."
Querevalu's frustrated search for the silvery,
stiletto-sized fish reflects a voracious, growing global demand for the
protein-rich fish meal, and oil, into which nearly Peru's entire anchovy
catch is converted. It also reflects unremitting cheating by commercial
fleets on quotas and other regulations designed to protect the species.
Not
only has overfishing of the Peruvian anchovy, or anchoveta, battered
the industry that makes Peru far and away the world's No. 1 fish meal
exporter, it has also raised alarm about food security in a nation that
had long been accustomed to cheap, abundant seafood.
The drop in
the anchoveta population has over the years affected the food chain, as
stocks of hundreds of bigger wild fish and marine animals that eat it
have also thinned.
Anchoveta thrives in the cold,
plankton-saturated Humboldt Current along the coast of Peru and Chile
and accounts for about a third of the global fishmeal industry used to
fatten farmed seafood and livestock, from
salmon in Norway to pigs in China. Like other small "forage fish" that
account for more than a third of the world's wild ocean fish catch,
nearly the entire anchoveta catch gets ground up into feed and rendered
into oil.
It is the "the most heavily exploited fish in world history," according to the U.N. Food and Agricultural Organization.
Peru's
government ordered deep cuts in what the country's 1,200-boat
commercial fleet could catch in October after anchoveta stocks plummeted
to about 5 million metric tons — at the low end of what fishermen would
bring in during previous years. While the small fish reproduce rapidly,
their overall population is now less than half its volume a decade ago,
said Patricia Majluf, a top Peruvian marine scientist.
The
government slashed the permitted commercial catch by two-thirds and set
rules meant to put more fish on dinner tables in a country whose rural
provinces are afflicted by some of the world's highest rates of child
malnourishment.
Yet the commercial fleet has continued to cheat, said Paul Phumpiu, Peru's vice minister of fisheries.
"They
have no social conscience," he told reporters Monday in announcing new
fines of nearly $3 million on commercial companies for illegally
harvesting more than 18,000 metric tons of juvenile anchoveta during the
three-month fishing season that ended Jan. 31.
"This resource
isn't only for the enrichment of a few. It's for the benefit of all of
us," Phumpiu said in an earlier interview. "It's a paradox, having a
resource so rich that it feeds other parts of the planet but barely
reaches Peruvians."
Peru's commercial fishing industry blames
climatic problems for the anchoveta's slide. But independent experts say
years of overfishing, lax enforcement and cheating on quotas and fines
have hurt the population. They also accuse the industry of rampant
underreporting of its catch and of endangering stocks by harvesting
juveniles.
Majluf said a one-year fishing ban should be imposed to rebuild the population.
Officials
balked at that idea, instead setting the lowest quota ever for the
commercial trawler fleet at just 810,000 tons for the fishing season
that just ended. The government will soon assess anchoveta stocks and
determine the quota for the next, mid-year season.
Phumpiu said
Peru also is boosting the number of its inspectors, from 60 to 260 to
begin with, along the 1,860-mile (3,000-kilometer) coastline and
increasing fines for unauthorized catches.
Skeptics doubt the new restrictions will work.
For
one thing, an estimated 400,000 tons of anchoveta caught annually goes
unreported. "That's the entire (annual) catch of Spain, or Italy," said
Juan Carlos Sueiro, a Cayetano Heredia University economist. It's value:
about $200 million.
There are also huge loopholes.
Anchoveta
quotas only apply to boats in the commercial fleet that works within
Peru's 200-mile territorial waters. Those vessels have been responsible
for about 94 percent of the catch.
But when boat-by-boat quotas were imposed in 2008, trawlers under 32 tons were exempted. Unrestricted, their numbers swelled.
"Everybody
around here got into fishing. Farmers sell their cattle and get into
fishing. Engineers and doctors, they have their profession. But on the
side, they buy boats," said Juan Ponce, administrator of the artisanal,
or small-time, fishing pier in Pisco, a three-hour drive south of Lima.
With
so much overfishing, particularly of anchoveta, fresh fish of all sizes
are now scarcer than ever for Peruvians, and seafood prices have risen
since 2009 at a rate four times that of other foods.
People "buy
more chicken than fish because chicken is cheaper," said Pedro Diaz
Sanchez, a wad of bills in his hand thickening as he sells hake by the
crate at Lima's Villa Maria del Triunfo fish market.
In fact,
whole anchoveta hasn't been available for years. Rendering factories now
pay roughly twice as much for anchoveta as wholesalers who cater to
human consumption. Peru earns about $2,000 a metric ton for fishmeal and
$2,800 a ton for fish oil, a popular ingredient in nutritional
supplements, and prices have more than doubled over the past decade.
Local supplies of fish also are hurt by laws that subsidize exports.
"It's
cheaper to export fish to Africa than to haul it to Huancavelica," said
Carlos Paredes, a San Martin de Porres University economist, referring
to a highlands Peruvian province where 55 percent of children under age 5
suffer from chronic malnutrition.
The powerful fishing industry
has fought efforts to trim quotas and raise taxes, while some commercial
fleet owners challenge in court a backlog of millions of dollars in
fines. Last year, fishermen in the northern port of Paita blocked
highways and sacked city hall to protest a quota on hake that they
considered too low. Two people died in clashes with police.
Hoping
to forestall similar unrest, and to get more fish to local markets, the
government in September mixed new restrictions on the big anchoveta
fleet with incentives for smaller boats. It barred the big, commercial
trawlers from within 10 miles of the coast. Previously, the first five
miles had been off-limits. Then it created a new category of
"medium-sized" boats — between 10 and 32 tons — with exclusive rights to
the 5-to-10-mile corridor.
The artisanal fleet of boats of less
than 10 tons was given exclusive rights to the first five miles, where
most anchoveta spawn.
The government decreed that the small and medium-sized boats would only be permitted to catch fish for human consumption.
But there is blatant cheating amid an almost complete absence of government policing.
At
Pisco's artisanal pier on a recent morning, workers removed six tons of
anchoveta from the turquoise-hued wooden trawler "El Tio" as pelicans
and boobies picked at the scraps.
The oily fish were loaded onto a
flatbed truck that navigated Pisco's dusty streets before disappearing
through a eucalyptus grove into an illegal fishmeal factory, one of 15
that Sueiro says operate up and down the coast.
Ponce, the pier
administrator, said dozens of the 300 boats at his pier similarly sell
anchoveta illegally, especially in these slow days of the Southern
Hemisphere summer when people aren't catching much else.
"The anchoveta is the only resource available year-round," said Ponce.
Sueiro, the economist, fears it could one day disappear as an industry, as other fisheries have.
"Twenty
years ago we caught nearly 3 million tons of sardines (a year)," he
said. "Now, they don't even capture a ton. Commercially, no one in Peru
lives off sardines anymore."